Power transmission

Friday Night Motor Swap: The $4,800 Lesson in Leeson Model Numbers and VFD Sizing

Posted on 2026-11-17 by Ingrid Nystrom

September 16, 2022, 4:47 p.m. My laptop was already in my bag when the phone buzzed. A food processing plant about 40 minutes south of us, one conveyor line down, and a plant engineer who sounded like he hadn't slept since Wednesday.

"We need a Leeson 1.5 HP motor and a VFD for our 5 HP unit by Saturday noon. Can you do it?"

I said yes before I checked anything. That was the first mistake — though not the expensive one.

Reading a Leeson Electric Motor Model Number Too Fast

The customer's motor tag read: Leeson 1.5 HP, 1725 RPM, 56C frame, single phase. I opened the catalog, matched HP and frame, and picked a unit. In and out, maybe four minutes.

What I didn't slow down for was the enclosure code. On a Leeson electric motor model number, HP and frame are only part of the story. The trailing characters tell you whether you're getting an open drip-proof (ODP) unit, a totally enclosed fan-cooled (TEFC) unit, or a washdown-duty motor. I matched the numbers and skipped the letters.

That plant hoses down their line every shift. Washdown area.

I ordered an ODP motor. Open. In a room where the floor is wet by design.

Nobody on our side caught it either. The supplier shipped what the PO said, the warehouse checked the box, and the box matched the PO. Everything lined up except the reality of where the motor was going.

What Size VFD for a 5 HP Motor? (Don't Do What I Did)

While I was in there, the customer asked for a VFD for their 5 HP motor on the same conveyor line. I ordered a 5 HP drive.

It arrived, mounted clean, powered up, and tripped on overload in under two minutes of run time.

Turns out the drive I bought was rated for variable torque loads — centrifugal pumps and fans, that kind of thing. A conveyor is a constant torque load. Same nameplate HP, very different current profile. The motor's FLA was higher than the drive's continuous output at constant torque, and the 1.15 service factor just made it worse.

Here's what I tell people now when they ask what size VFD for a 5 HP motor: the HP is the least interesting number on the page. You need the full load amps, the service factor, the load type (constant vs. variable torque), and the drive's output rating at that load type. Match HP to HP and you'll be right maybe 60% of the time — which, in a production environment, might as well be zero.

Anyway. The drive tripped. The line was still down. And I had a washdown-room motor sitting in a box that was basically useless.

The Saturday Morning Call

My warehouse guy unboxed the motor at 10:15 Saturday morning and called me.

"This one's open. You know they wash this area down, right?"

Ten seconds of silence. That sick, sinking feeling before your brain fully catches up to how bad it is.

If we'd installed that motor anyway, it probably would've run three weeks before moisture got into the windings. Likely on their busiest production day. Likely with a phone call I really didn't want to receive.

We scrambled. Found a TEFC replacement locally at a distributor markup. Drove it down Saturday afternoon. The correct 5 HP constant-torque drive was a Sunday delivery from a regional rep who picked up the phone when he probably shouldn't have.

By Monday morning, the line was running. Nobody at the plant knew how close it came to a week-long outage.

The Invoice, Roughly

Lost on that one job, give or take a couple hundred:

  • ODP motor that was never going to work: $340 (restocking fee ate $85 of the return)
  • Wrong VFD: $610 (returned, minus shipping both ways — call it $640 all in)
  • Locally sourced TEFC replacement at distributor markup: +$190 over catalog
  • Saturday delivery and Sunday drive fees: $425
  • Labor my team burned on reinstall: roughly 14 hours across two techs

Add up the markup, the fees, the freight, and the payroll, and we were staring at about $4,800. Maybe $4,600 — I'd have to pull the invoice lines to get it exact, and honestly it hurts to look at. (Prices based on our distributor and freight quotes, September 2022; your rates will differ.)

The customer paid the original quote. We ate the rest. That's how it works when you're the one who made the error.

The Two More I Collected That Fall

I'd love to say that was the only expensive lesson that fall. It was not.

In October, we installed a servo motor control retrofit for the same plant — three-axis motion on a packaging line. I wired the encoder A/B channels based on the drive manufacturer's default diagram and didn't cross-check against the servo motor's own data sheet. Different vendors use different A/B phase definitions. Power up, position fault, red light, no motion. We spent four hours on the phone with two tech lines before a senior engineer on the motor side said, "Swap A and B and try again." Fixed in ten minutes. Four hours, two techs, plus a return visit the next day.

In November, an industrial electric actuator job went sideways in the same spirit. I set the extended and retracted limits using the actuator's factory defaults. On site, the first full-extension cycle drove the rod face-first into a mechanical hard stop the customer had welded in after our survey. Bending the rod cost about $270 in parts and a five-day lead time on a replacement. What we should have done — what we now do — is verify the customer's physical stroke envelope, not just the actuator's rated stroke.

What We Changed

By the end of that year I had a one-page pre-order checklist taped inside the front cover of our catalog binder. Honestly, it's embarrassingly simple. But we've caught 31 potential order errors with it in the past two years, so it stays.

The short version:

  1. Read the full model number, out loud. Not just HP and frame. Enclosure, mounting, shaft, voltage, phase — the whole string. If the suffix doesn't match the environment, stop.
  2. For any VFD order, grab the motor's FLA and service factor first. Then check the drive's constant-torque vs. variable-torque rating. HP matching is a starting point, not an answer.
  3. For servo installations, cross-check encoder wiring against the motor data sheet, not just the drive manual. Ten minutes now versus four hours later.
  4. For electric actuators, confirm the customer's physical stroke and any hard stops before programming limits. The catalog stroke is the maximum. The site is what matters.

If you've ever had a Friday afternoon order turn into a Saturday morning problem, you know the feeling. The mistake itself stings. The part that lingers is knowing how easy it would've been to avoid.

I keep the checklist because I'd rather look careful than confident. Turns out those aren't always the same thing.

Ingrid Nystrom

Ingrid Nystrom

Ingrid Nystrom is an independent rotating equipment reliability analyst covering gear units, bearings, couplings, lubrication, condition monitoring, and failure investigation. She uses ISO 20816-9 vibration evaluation for gear units alongside temperature, oil-debris, noise, alignment, and trend-baseline measurements to distinguish developing faults from normal variation. Her maintenance articles help reliability teams set alert limits, prioritize inspections, plan corrective work, and compare lifecycle consequences before downtime becomes critical.

Leave a technical comment